I taught organic chemistry at Reed for 32 years (1989-2021) and at Pomona College for 4 years before that. Chem 201 was always a ‘big lift’ for me each year and I know that I demanded an equally big effort, if not more so, from the huge number of students who took the class. It was stressful and demanding for everyone involved. Even so, organic chemistry or ‘o chem’, (or ‘orgo’, if you insist) has been my favorite area of chemistry ever since my sophomore year of college (1972-73) and I have always looked forward to the opportunity to introduce a new crop of students to something that I had devoted so much of myself to. Thank you, students!!! You gave me everything you could and no o chem prof could have ever found a better set of comrades.
I also want to send a big “Thank You” to my colleagues in the Reed chemistry department who supported me in ways large and small, and to my colleagues in the IT/AV departments who supported our web sites and computer+projection systems over the years. I asked for a lot from all of you and you delivered. <3
Finally, I owe a very special “Thank You” to Tony Moreno, Digital Project Manager. This version (and many previous versions) of the Chem 201 and Chem 201-202 web sites would never have existed without Tony’s contributions. Tony, I see your creativity and thoughtfulness everywhere I look. =)
]]>I’ll give you the gory details about quiz #3 in a moment, but I want to say this: students’ first encounter with the acid-base equilibria and chemical reactions (usually nucleophilic substitution reactions) of organic chemistry has been problematic for as long as I have been teaching organic chemistry (over 30 years). I would like to think that there is a better way to teach this material, but I haven’t found it yet. Still, there are some silver linings in all this. Read on.
This story contains several parts. To begin, I will define three scoring ranges, and then I will tell you how many students earned scores in each range on each quiz. That way you will be able to see the trends in class quiz scores and compare them to your own. Then I will report on 2018 scores so that you can see how the scores might evolve as the semester goes along. And, finally, I will offer some advice.
Scoring Ranges
So what happened on quizzes 1-3? Here are the percentages of students who earned scores in each category.
In-class quizzes
The numbers speak for themselves. The percentage of students earning less than 60% on in-class quiz #3 more than tripled from quiz #2. And nearly every person in the class, regardless of their actual scores, saw some kind of drop in their quiz scores (only 2 people out of 64 scored higher on quiz #3 than they had on quizzes #1 and #2).
Take-home quizzes
Interestingly, the entire class took take-home quiz #3 (64 students) which was not the case with earlier take-homes (56 students #1, 58 students #2). Probably this fact alone tells you how much harder quiz #3 felt to everyone. The median score on take-home #3 was a few percentage points lower than on previous quizzes, but the take-home had the desired effect: even though only 42% of students earned satisfactory scores in-class, 88% did so on the take-home.
Last year (2018)
I don’t want to dwell on these data because each year is assigned different quizzes, but even with that excuse, you can see that last year’s class encountered the same shock on quiz #3. You can also see the “shock” was followed by steady increases in the percentage earning a satisfactory grade: 45% (#3) -> 55% (#4) -> 68% (#5). (And while I haven’t displayed the data, the take-home scores on quizzes were always much higher than the in-class scores.)
Advice
Don’t give up. Unless you really, really, really want to.
While a couple of students inevitably decide that their academic path through Reed lies in a much different direction than organic chemistry (and whatever goes with it), the vast majority of Chem 201 students keep working at organic chemistry. And nearly all of them find ways to become successful. Still, it is hard work. You need to find time in your busy schedule. You need to learn to focus on unfamiliar (and maybe not-so-appealing?) material to a greater degree than you have so far. It may feel uncomfortable at first, but you will get used to it.
Finally, you need to find and use resources that can help you learn and retain the material. What are these resources? Me. Tutors. Practice activities: book problems, making drawings, writing-speaking-reading, using concepts. Your classmates. YOU.
Make a commitment to helping yourself and to helping others as well. If you aren’t ready to explain something to your classmate, ask them for help answering your questions (and really listen when they try to do it). Whichever way things flow, your engagement with others in study will not only encourage them, it will encourage you as well. Trust me.
]]>Halloween was celebrated up and down Eliot Hall yesterday. Nearly everyone in class found their way over to the President’s Office to grab treats (mostly cookies, but also yummy hot cider, and more). And, 6 or 7 Chem 201 students showed up for the morning class already decked out in costumes. I coaxed Victoria “League of Her Own” Miller and Ana “Link” Jed into taking a picture with me. Thank you for playing along.

But let me cut straight to the surprising content, this story is not about using a smartphone instead of doing something else, it is about being near your phone while doing something else. The reporter, Shankar Vedantam, describes work done by a team of Harvard psychologists (their names are in the transcript – look them up):
Vedantam: They had volunteers come in to take cognitive tests, but there was a catch. Some volunteers were told to leave their smartphones in another room. Some were told to leave the phones in a bag or a pocket. And others were told to leave their phones on the desk next to them as they took the test. Now, all the phones were on silent. But big differences emerged between the volunteers as they took the test, especially when it came to understanding and solving novel problems.
And then one of the psychologists (Ward) delivers the punchline:
]]>Ward: What we found is that people did better on these tasks the farther their phones were from them. So those who had their phones in another room did significantly better than those who had their phones on the desk right in front of them. And then those who had their phones in their pockets or their bags were sort of in the middle, between those two groups.
If you are currently in a financial bind and feel unable to make, or even uncomfortable making, all of your purchases for Chem 201 and your other courses, Reed College is prepared to help you through this! The following instructions were provided by the offices of Student Life and Financial Aid this week, and they are standing by.
Please don’t hesitate to get the assistance we can offer. Remember that clicker usage is totaled up every day of class and two days have slipped past already. Likewise, a few days have already elapsed on the Sapling homework clock for Day 1. But clickers and Sapling need to be purchased, so don’t let a temporary financial problem derail your academic work. Here’s what you do:
First step, contact Sandy in Financial Aid. Sandy is the Director of Financial Aid and has considerable experience rendering assistance to students who are concerned about paying for textbooks and course materials. The financial binds that she routinely deals with include such things as a student who did not accept their full financial aid package, errors with aid dispursement, a student who is struggling to find work-study opportunities, and students whose financial situation has changed and they haven’t had a chance to notify Financial Aid. Sandy cannot solve every problem, but if she runs out of tools, she can refer you to other appropriate financial resources. So start with Sandy in Financial Aid.
Another thing to do: work with the Reed Bookstore. The Bookstore allows students to set up a payment plan for textbooks over the course of the semester so students can pay off books and course materials in smaller amounts over time (that’s instead of making one lump sum payment for everything on day one of classes). If you think that could help ease your current bind, please contact Jill Charvat in the Bookstore to set up a payment plan (Jill is the Accounting Supervisor).
And, as a last word, let me add that not all problems are financial. If you need assistance, or have concerns about another student who might, please contact the Care Team (careteam@reed.edu, 503-777-7521, or drop by Eliot Hall 218 between 9-5 pm, M-F).
]]>Reed’s first week of classes is short because Monday is Labor Day. This means that two Chem 201 sessions, the Monday afternoon lecture and the Monday evening lab lecture, cannot meet. And because the course schedule ties the Monday and Tuesday lectures together, the Tuesday, Sept. 3, morning lecture is cancelled too. Our first days (Day 1) of lecture will be Wednesday, Sept. 4, and Thursday, Sept. 5. Your attendance at your scheduled lecture section on Day 1 is absolutely required.
The Labor Day holiday does not impact the lab schedule. Our first (Week 1) lab sessions will meet Tuesday-Friday, Sept. 3-6. Check the schedule for your lab day (Tu/W sections meet 1:10-5 pm, Th/F sections meet 12:30-4:20 pm) and show up in Rm. 209 at the scheduled time or maybe a few minutes earlier.
What will you be doing in lecture and lab? What do you need to do before class and lab so that you are prepared? These are excellent questions and the following instructions will guide you. Note: the following instructions have already been sent to all registered 201 students by email. Read, review, act as your situation requires.
Greetings,
And welcome back to Reed and to organic chemistry (Chem 201). We will be
sending you 4 emails this holiday weekend and we would like you to read all of them before
Tuesday. These emails will tell you just about everything you need to know
so that you can be ready for lab this week (meets Tu-F) and lecture.
4 emails may sound like a lot of information (it is) so let us break
it down a bit. The emails that follow this one (emails #2-#4) will be
sent out as soon as we can put them together. They will focus on
preparation for lecture: syllabus, teaching methods & expectations,
clickers, and
Sapling homework. Highlights from these yet-to-be-written emails:
This email (#1) focuses on the Chem 201 lab. Lab will meet every day this week, Tu-F, so read carefully.
Lab lectures
Lab sessions
For the first lab,
come directly to the o chem lab, Rm. 209, on your lab day (attend the
section you registered for). Starting times are 1:10 PM Tu/W and 12:30 PM Th/F. Expect to put in a full
afternoon so maybe equip yourself with a snack to get you through a long
lab session.
Whew! That should cover things for lab this week. If you have questions, don’t hesitate to contact us. Thank you for taking the time to read this email and to start work.
Now on to email #2…
Alan Shusterman and Alicia McGhee
Chem 201 instructional staff
#2 Prepare for the first lecture (W 2:30, Th 10:30, E314). Note: the lecture on Tu, Sept 3 has been cancelled.
(Reading note: This is email #3 in the Day 0 series. Email #1 was sent to you on 8/31 and described our lab meetings for this week and lab policies. Email #2 regarding our syllabus and classroom operations was sent earlier this morning. Please look for these emails and read them first.)
The new business in this email concerns electronic polling devices or “clickers”. I expect you to bring a clicker to every lecture this semester. They are not needed for lab or lab lecture.
The accuracy of your clicker responses will not be graded, but your participation (the number of responses you provide) will have impact your grade (in a relatively small way). I rely on clickers to give me accurate, real-time ideas about how a class thinks about the material we are covering. I do not look at individual answers. So please provide the best quality answers that you can manage for each question. Right or wrong, your best guess is useful to me. After I count the first round of clicks, I will often give the class a chance to discuss answers and click again. More info about grades and clickers can be found here.
QT2 devices only. Chem 201/202 will use the Turning Technology QT2 clickers. These devices have a complete A-Z, 0-9 keypad and LCD display, and they are powered by 2 easily replaceable AAA batteries. If you have some other kind of clicker, or used a mobile device in place of clicker last year in Chem 101/102, you will need to purchase a new QT2 clicker from the Reed College bookstore. You will also need to purchase a one-year subscription and create a student account at the Turning Technologies web site in order to use your clicker (and receive course credit for your clicks).
Cost. A new QT2 clicker + 1-year subscription costs $58 at the bookstore. If you already have a QT2, you can just purchase a 1-year subscription for $25.99. (Note: these are 2018 prices and they may have changed.)
Clicker Returns. If you decide at any time that you no longer need your clicker, you can return yours to the Reed bookstore for some kind of refund. In the past, the bookstore has told me that students “have the first 2 weeks of classes to return the clickers with the receipt for a full refund. The only difference is the subscription code scratch-off must be fully intact. If it has been scratched off we are unable to refund it. After the first 2 weeks it is a 60% refund through November.”
Mobile device app subscription warning: Chem 101/2 students who used their mobile devices as clickers had to download a Turning Technologies app and were able to buy a subscription through the app. This will NOT work for the QT2 clicker. See the instructions provided by the bookstore or the instructions in the attached file.
Where to go next. After you obtain a clicker, open the attached file and set up your student account and start your subscription. It is not enough to just bring a clicker to class. You need an account and a subscription. Otherwise, I won’t be able to give you credit for your responses.
If you are hesitating because you are wavering in your commitment to Chem 201 and the cost of the clicker/subscription are high, that is fine. Hesitate. My grading policy forgives 20% of your clicker responses, that is, you only need to respond to 80% of my clicker questions over the course of the semester to earn full clicker credit. You can hold off on clicking for a few days and suffer no penalties at all.
Clicker advice:
1. Most lectures will pose a clicker question within the first few minutes of class. When you arrive at class, get your device out! Don’t drop it into the bottom of your backpack under your laptop, lunch, raincoat, where it can’t be reached.
2. How you solve an organic chemistry problem matters, even clicker problems. I will be singing the following song all semester long: Organic chemistry is learned and practiced through your fingers, that is, you need to draw structural formulas before you give an answer. The alternative, constructing formulas in your head, is not nearly as effective, and often doesn’t work at all. My recommendation is this: Have your pencil or pen handy when faced with a clicker question. Before you click in your answer, draw the answer(s) you are considering, and look at them. Don’t just stare at the screen and click.
On to email #4…
Alan
PS Reminders: Prices and technologies are constantly shifting. The information I have provided here may be out of date. Please let me know if you encounter errors in either prices or set-up instructions, and I will post corrections online. Thank you.
Sapling provides homework problems that are tailored to specific course topics so you will be seeing assignments for each day that match the topics covered on that day.
Please go to Sapling Learning on the Chem 201 web site to learn about:
The homework assignment schedule has not been posted yet, but you will be able to find it on the Homework page next week (I will announce this by email).
How homework is used to calculate your course grade is described in the FAQ page.
A perfectly reasonable question, and one that deserves an instructive response. But I hesitate to answer. Why? First, I think it is important to know that, practically speaking, there is enough time to work on your fall semester courses during the fall. You shouldn’t feel compelled to make your academic year longer than it already is. Second, I’m worried about fueling student anxiety. Whether your goal is to earn an A or to simply pass the course, you can do this without summer study. I am not trying to make a philosophical point, but just reporting on what I have seen. Hardly any students study for organic chemistry before the semester begins and they do just fine.
Now that my cards are on the table, and you understand that summer study is completely optional, I will freely admit that there are many sound reasons for delving into a subject before you study it formally. I have even done it myself on occasion. So, with all that in mind, here are three suggestions for those who are interested in serious preparation.
#1. Review key topics from Chem 101/102. Chem 201 leans heavily on a number of topics that are developed in the 100-level courses. A logical way to prepare for 201 is to make sure your 101/102 foundation is strong. This approach also has the advantage of practicality. You probably still have your 101/102 course materials, so you can more easily dig them up for review and practice. Here’s a list of 101/102 topics that I think are especially important for creating a strong foundation for Chem 201/202.
#2. Learn/Practice study skills. Many successful 201/202 students have told me that they became successful only after they adopted new ways of studying. That makes perfect sense to me. It isn’t enough to be “academically gifted” or “hard-working” or “attend all classes and take good notes” (although all of these things help). Chem 201/202 ask you to master concepts and skills that don’t appear much, if at all, in Chem 101/102, and achieving these goals usually means cultivating one or more additional (and possibly new) skills and habits. Take a look at this list (under construction) of “new” study skills and consider whether some summer practice might be helpful. Planting the seeds of even one new skill could be helpful. (Bonus: you will probably learn a little organic chemistry along the way.)
#3. Study organic chemistry. Here’s the “obvious” suggestion, study organic chemistry with some kind of organic chemistry textbook before the semester starts. There is nothing particularly remarkable about this except that your book will be your sole guide. You don’t have to complete any particular list of topics. You can skip around, sample a little of this and a little of that if you like. Here is a list of books that have something to offer.
There is also the question of how to study when you work with a book. #2. Learn/Practice study skills contains some important tips, but if you’ve gotten this far, you’ve already decided your skills are fine. So let’s put aside the notion that you want to touch lightly on this or that, and you really want to “go for it”. In that case, you need to do 3 things: read in an organized fashion, learn to draw (correctly, clearly, quickly) chemical structural formulas, energy diagrams, reactions and reaction mechanisms, and finally memorize what you are learning. For more on read-draw-memorize, see these tips (under construction).
]]>All of these topics should look at least a little familiar, but how well will you recall and (even more important) be able to use them next fall? One simple way to make sure you get off to a good start in Chem 201 is to review these key topics from 101/102.
Here is a detailed list of topics that you can use to guide your 101/102 review. It includes a large number of pointers regarding key facts, skills, and explanations. To put it another way, it’s a long list so don’t let it overwhelm. Pick-and-choose a few topics for summer study, and we will get the rest of it in 201. (Note: my other two summer review suggestions also cover some of the material on this list.)
(added 8 Aug, 2019) An alternative to my detailed list exists and that is to dive into a smallish (250 page) book, “Preparation for Organic Chemistry” by I. David Reingold. The book is available in paperback and also in a $9.99 Kindle-friendly version. The author describes the book in this way, “Reviews material from general chemistry that is relevant to organic, set in an organic context”. I haven’t seen more of the book than the Table of Contents, but even that limited topic list overlaps well with the topic list that I give you below.
Chem 101/102 Topics that Apply to Organic Chemistry
Lewis Structures
Molecular Geometry
Resonance Structures (= resonance contributors = resonance forms)
Quantum Mechanical Models of Electronic Structure
Intermolecular Forces
Structure-Energy Correlations
Chemical Equilibria & Concentration
Chemical Reaction Rates (Kinetics)
When you think about this degree of standardization, you might guess that just about any college-level material you study will be helpful and you would be exactly right, but as I suggest below, a textbook might not be the best choice for summer work. Instead, I suggest that you find one of the “supplement” style books that I list and work with it instead. Notice that I say, “work,” and not “read.” That’s because all of the supplements are workbooks where you read a little and then do some problems. I think the following two paragraphs (quoted from To the Student in Pushing Electrons) says it best,
“I have only three instructions. First, supply an answer wherever a line appears under a blank space. The correct answer might be a word, a number, a structure, or some arrows. Second, don’t look up the correct answers until you have made a serious try at doing it yourself. Third if you plan to just look up the right answers and transcribe them, return the book and get your money back.
The program uses two effective learning devices: active involvement and repetition. You will participate actively in the learning process. Because so much of the academic experience consists of receiving information, it should be refreshing to work through a program using your own wits. You will see an example of an operation and then carry it out several times as the supporting material is gradually removed. The approach is methodical. Some of you will find that you can accelerate your trip through certain sections. But the program has been written in the hope that none of you will ever feel abandoned. Expect to spend a total of 10 to 14 hours to complete the program.”
4 Books To Consider:
Decisions, decisions. If you have access to only one book (even the textbook), use what you have. If you have access to 2 or 3 supplements, then here’s a way to decide. First, think about time. If you are looking for a small time commitment, choose “Pushing Electrons”. Second, if you are ready to commit to a more substantial summer prep, consider writing style. Read 3-4 pages of “Second Language” and “Arrow Pushing”. Which style meets your needs? Go with that book!
]]>
*Dr. (?) Fung has produced a number of chemistry web videos. I have only listened to one more, Meditation in Chemistry, and I just wish it were longer than 96 seconds. What beautiful music!
]]>